How traffic is switched

How Vitess signals traffic cutover for Reshard and MoveTables

Related persistent Vitess objects #

As the objects or keys noted below are stored in the topo server and cached locally, the processes involved will refresh their topo data throughout the cutover process. For example, each tablet on the source and target shards that are involved in a VReplication workflow will refresh their topo data multiple times as the state of things transition during the cutover. If we are not able to confirm that all tablets involved in a VReplication worfklow are able to refresh their topo data then the cutover command — e.g. vtctlclient SwitchTraffic — will cancel the operation and return an error indicating which tablet(s) is unhealthy (including --dry_run executions).

VSchema #

A VSchema allows you to describe how data is organized within keyspaces and shards.

Shard Info #

The global topo contains one Shard key per keyspace which then contains one key per shard that has been created within the keyspace. For each shard that is healthy there is an attribute is_primary_serving which is set to true. The other shards which have been created but are still not healthy and serving within the keyspace will not have this attribute set. Here is an example shard info record from an unsharded keyspace named commerce (without the --cell flag being passed the global topo base path is used):

$ vtctlclient --server=localhost:15999 TopoCat -- --decode_proto '/keyspaces/commerce/shards/0/Shard'
primary_alias:{cell:"zone1" uid:100} primary_term_start_time:{seconds:1650341417 nanoseconds:374817485} is_primary_serving:true

SrvKeyspace #

Each cell has a SrvKeyspace key in the local topo (per cell info) for each keyspace. For each tablet type (primary/replica) there is one partitions object. The partitions objects contain all of the current shards in the keyspace. For sharded keyspaces, the tablets which are healthy and serving have a key range specified for that shard.

Also the primary can contain a query_service_disabled attribute which is set to false during resharding cutovers. This tells the primary in that shard to reject any queries made to it, as a signal to vtgate in case vtgate routes queries to this primary during the cutover or before it discovers the new serving graph. Here is an example using the same unsharded commerce keyspace and here we specify the --cell flag so that cell's topo base path — stored in its CellInfo record in the global topo — is used:

$ vtctlclient --server=localhost:15999 TopoCat -- --decode_proto '/cells/zone1/CellInfo'
server_address:"localhost:2379" root:"/vitess/zone1"

$ vtctlclient --server=localhost:15999 TopoCat -- --decode_proto --cell=zone1 '/keyspaces/commerce/SrvKeyspace'
partitions:{served_type:PRIMARY shard_references:{name:"0"}} partitions:{served_type:REPLICA shard_references:{name:"0"}} partitions:{served_type:RDONLY shard_references:{name:"0"}}

Routing Rules #

Routing Rules are stored in the RoutingRules key within the global topo. Routing Rules contain a list of table-specific routes. You can route a table for all or specific tablet types to another table in the same or different keyspace. Here is an example using the same commerce keyspace where we have an active MoveTables workflow to move tables to the customer keyspace but we have not switched any traffic yet:

$ vtctlclient --server=localhost:15999 TopoCat -- --decode_proto '/RoutingRules'
rules:{from_table:"corder@rdonly" to_tables:"commerce.corder"} rules:{from_table:"customer.corder" to_tables:"commerce.corder"} rules:{from_table:"customer.corder@replica" to_tables:"commerce.corder"} rules:{from_table:"customer@rdonly" to_tables:"commerce.customer"} rules:{from_table:"customer.customer@rdonly" to_tables:"commerce.customer"} rules:{from_table:"customer.corder@rdonly" to_tables:"commerce.corder"} rules:{from_table:"customer@replica" to_tables:"commerce.customer"} rules:{from_table:"corder@replica" to_tables:"commerce.corder"} rules:{from_table:"commerce.corder@replica" to_tables:"commerce.corder"} rules:{from_table:"commerce.corder@rdonly" to_tables:"commerce.corder"} rules:{from_table:"commerce.customer@rdonly" to_tables:"commerce.customer"} rules:{from_table:"corder" to_tables:"commerce.corder"} rules:{from_table:"customer.customer@replica" to_tables:"commerce.customer"} rules:{from_table:"commerce.customer@replica" to_tables:"commerce.customer"} rules:{from_table:"customer" to_tables:"commerce.customer"} rules:{from_table:"customer.customer" to_tables:"commerce.customer"}
In practice you would instead typically view the routing rules via the dedicated vtctl GetRoutingRules command which will return the rules for all keyspaces in the topo.

How VTGate routes a query #

This section gives a simplified logic used to determine which keyspace and table vtgate will route a simple query of the form select * from t1 where id = 1 (a read query) or insert into t1 (id, val) values (1,'abc') (a write query).

  • Check to see if t1 has an appropriate routing rule defined. If so, use the specified target table as an alias for t1
  • Locate the keyspace for t1 using the VSchema
  • For a non-sharded keyspace locate the appropriate tablet (primary, by default) from the (cached) SrvKeyspace local (per cell) topo record.
  • For a sharded keyspace the SrvKeyspace record is used to find the currently active shards. This is done by checking the list of partitions for the specific tablet type selected for the query (primary, by default, for reads and writes) and selecting the ones whose query_service_disabled is not set and whose is_primary_serving is true.
  • Finally, based on the vindex for the table from the cached VSchema (stored in the global topo), the shard for the relevant row is computed based on the keyrange to which the id is mapped to using the declared vindex function/type.

Changes made to the topo when traffic is switched #

This document outlines the steps involved in the cutover process of MoveTables and Reshard workflows when traffic is switched from the source tables/shards to the target tables/shards. We use the resharding flow provided in the local examples and show the relevant snippets from the topo for each step in the workflow.

Note: Items in italics are topo keys and the following snippet the value of the key

What happens when a Reshard is cutover #

For brevity we only show the records for the 80- shard. There will be similar records for the -80 shard.

Before Resharding, after -80/80- shards are created #

Only shard 0 has is_primary_serving set to true. The SrvKeyspace record only has references to 0 for both primary and replica.

global/keyspaces/customer/shards/0/Shard

primary_alias:{cell:"zone1" uid:200}
primary_term_start_time:{seconds:1627465761 nanoseconds:600070156}
is_primary_serving:true

global/keyspaces/customer/shards/80-/Shard

primary_alias:{cell:"zone1" uid:400}
primary_term_start_time:{seconds:1627465833 nanoseconds:536524508}
key_range:{start:"\x80"}

zone1/keyspaces/customer/SrvKeyspace

partitions:{served_type:PRIMARY shard_references:{name:"0"}}
partitions:{served_type:REPLICA shard_references:{name:"0"}}

After replica traffic is switched (aka SwitchReads) #

Shard 0 still has the is_primary_serving set as true. The primary partition is still the same.

The replica partition has the following changes:

  • Two more shard_references for -80 and 80-
  • Key ranges are specified for these shards
  • The key range for shard 0 has been removed
  • query_service_disabled is set to true for shard 0

global/keyspaces/customer/shards/0/Shard

primary_alias:{cell:"zone1" uid:200}
primary_term_start_time:{seconds:1627466189 nanoseconds:587021377}
is_primary_serving:true

global/keyspaces/customer/shards/80-/Shard

primary_alias:{cell:"zone1" uid:400}
primary_term_start_time:{seconds:1627466263 nanoseconds:16201490}
key_range:{start:"\x80"}``

zone1/keyspaces/customer/SrvKeyspace

partitions:{served_type:PRIMARY shard_references:{name:"0"}}

partitions:{served_type:REPLICA
shard_references:{name:"-80" key_range:{end:"\x80"}}
shard_references:{name:"80-" key_range:{start:"\x80"}}
shard_tablet_controls:{name:"0" query_service_disabled:true}
shard_tablet_controls:{name:"-80" key_range:{end:"\x80"}}
shard_tablet_controls:{name:"80-" key_range:{start:"\x80"}}}

After primary traffic is switched (aka SwitchWrites) #

  • is_primary_serving is removed from shard 0
  • is_primary_serving is added to shards -80 and 80-
  • In the primary partition the shards -80 and 80- are added with associated key ranges
  • In the primary partition the key range for shard 0 are removed
  • The replica partition is the same as in the previous step

global/keyspaces/customer/shards/0/Shard

primary_alias:{cell:"zone1" uid:200}
primary_term_start_time:{seconds:1627466636 nanoseconds:405646818}

global/keyspaces/customer/shards/80-/Shard

primary_alias:{cell:"zone1" uid:400}
primary_term_start_time:{seconds:1627466710 nanoseconds:579634511}
key_range:{start:"\x80"}
is_primary_serving:true

zone1/keyspace/customer/SrvKeyspace

partitions:{served_type:PRIMARY
shard_references:{name:"-80" key_range:{end:"\x80"}}
shard_references:{name:"80-"
key_range:{start:"\x80"}}} {name:"0"}

partitions:{served_type:REPLICA
shard_references:{name:"-80" key_range:{end:"\x80"}}
shard_references:{name:"80-" key_range:{start:"\x80"}}}
shard_tablet_controls:{name:"0" query_service_disabled:true}
shard_tablet_controls:{name:"-80" key_range:{end:"\x80"}}
shard_tablet_controls:{name:"80-" key_range:{start:"\x80"}}

What happens when a MoveTables workflow is cutover #

Before MoveTables is initiated #

VSchema for the source keyspace contains the table name, so vtgate routes to that keyspace

During MoveTables #

Both the source and target now contain the tables and both VSchemas refer to them. However we have routing rules that map the tables for each tablet type from the target keyspace to the other

global/RoutingRules

rules:{from_table:"customer" to_tables:"commerce.customer"}
rules:{from_table:"customer.customer" to_tables:"commerce.customer"}
rules:{from_table:"customer@replica" to_tables:"commerce.customer"}
rules:{from_table:"customer.customer@replica" to_tables:"commerce.customer"}

On switching replica traffic to target #

The routing rules for replicas are updated to map the table on the source to the target

global/RoutingRules

rules:{from_table:"customer.customer" to_tables:"commerce.customer"} rules:{from_table:"commerce.customer@replica" to_tables:"customer.customer"}
rules:{from_table:"customer" to_tables:"commerce.customer"}
rules:{from_table:"customer@replica" to_tables:"customer.customer"}

On switching primary traffic #

The routing rules for the primary are updated to map the table on the source to the target. In addition the tables are added to the “denylist” on the source keyspace which vttablet uses to reject writes for tables that have moved. The denylist/routing rules are temporary and can be removed since the moved tables will only appear in the target VSchema

global/RoutingRules

rules:{from_table:"commerce.customer@replica" to_tables:"customer.customer"}
rules:{from_table:"customer.customer@replica" to_tables:"customer.customer"}
rules:{from_table:"commerce.customer" to_tables:"customer.customer"}
rules:{from_table:"customer" to_tables:"customer.customer"}

global/keyspaces/commerce/shards/0/Shard

primary_alias:{cell:"zone1" uid:100}
primary_term_start_time:{seconds:1627477340 nanoseconds:740407602}
tablet_controls:{tablet_type:PRIMARY denylisted_tables:"customer"}
is_primary_serving:true

Miscellaneous Notes: #

  • In VReplication workflows, cutovers are performed manually by the user executing the noted vtctl commands
  • SwitchReads and SwitchWrites are deprecated terms from the “v1” workflows and are now replaced by SwitchTraffic and ReverseTraffic in the “v2” workflows . This section mentions both terms since the nomenclature has changed in recent versions and the v1 names may be more well known.
  • The term SwitchReads refers to switching traffic for replica and rdonly tablets. Of course this is by definition read-only traffic. Traffic to the primary tablets is not affected. This is equivalent to SwitchTraffic for replica and rdonly tablets (if you do not specify primary as a tablet_type for the SwitchTraffic command).
  • SwitchWrites refers to switching all traffic for the primary tablets. Equivalent to SwitchTraffic for primary tablet types.
  • SwitchReads and SwitchWrites can also reverse traffic based on the options/parameters provided to them